A federal judge in Maine ruled on Friday that the Hermon School Department violated the First Amendment and state law when its school committee refused to give a local congregation a year-long lease for Sunday worship at Hermon High School.
Chief U.S. District Judge Lance E. Walker issued the decision in Bangor after a bench trial. The plaintiffs were The Pines Church and its pastor, Matt Gioia. The judge found that a majority of the school committee acted with discriminatory animus toward the church's religious identity and beliefs. He held that this violated the church's free speech and free exercise rights and Maine's public accommodations law.
The committee had earlier voted 4-1 to let the congregation use the building only month to month. It turned down the church's requests for a six-month or twelve-month agreement. The church argued that a short, uncertain arrangement made it hard to plan services or build a steady life in the community.
In his ruling, Judge Walker wrote that if a public school's facilities are available for public use, a religious organization cannot be denied access because it is a religious organization. The court found it more likely than not that discriminatory animus was a motivating factor in the committee's decision.
The ruling has limits. The judge did not order the school department to sign the longer lease the church wanted. What the court did settle is that the reason behind the refusal was unlawful. The school committee has not said whether it will appeal.
A building is not the church
I want to be fair to the men and women who serve on a school committee. They are neighbors, they give their evenings to a thankless job, and I do not doubt that most of them believe they were protecting the public schools. The court has now said that something went wrong in how this church was treated, and a fair-minded person should receive that finding soberly. Grace toward the people does not mean silence about the principle.
The principle is old and plain. In America, a government body may not open its doors to the Rotary club, the dance studio and the youth league, and then shut them on a congregation because of what that congregation believes. Our founders did not write the First Amendment to protect the Christian only when he is convenient. They wrote it so that no officeholder, in any decade, could decide whose faith is welcome and whose is not.
There is a larger matter here, and it is the one that has stood in my mind all week. The Pines Church meets in a high school because it has no steeple of its own yet. And that tells you something the lawyers cannot. The first Christians had no buildings at all. They met in upper rooms, in homes, along riverbanks, in catacombs. The gospel did not wait on a lease.
"For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them." (Matthew 18:20)
Read that again, my friend. The Lord does not say where two or three have secured a favorable contract. He says where they are gathered in His name. A gymnasium, a cafeteria, a living room, a field. The presence of Christ is not leased from the county, and no committee vote can revoke it.
That is a comfort to a pastor who has been told to renew his permission every thirty days. It is also a word for the rest of us who sit in comfortable pews and take our freedom for granted. The apostle's charge to the early believers was plain:
"Not forsaking the assembling of ourselves together, as the manner of some is; but exhorting one another: and so much the more, as ye see the day approaching." (Hebrews 10:25)
Freedom to assemble is a gift of God, defended in this case by an ordinary court doing an ordinary duty. Honor the judge who upheld it. Honor the officials who now must reconsider. And do not mistake the lease for the thing itself. Whether a congregation worships in a rented gym or a cathedral, the question that matters most is the same one it has always been: has each person in the room been reconciled to God through Jesus Christ, who died for sinners and rose again?
A school board can open or close a door. It cannot open or close the kingdom. Only the Savior does that, and He has never turned away the one who comes to Him.