Michigan has the weakest state protections for religious nonprofits in the country, and Alabama has the strongest, according to the 2026 Faith and Freedom Index released this week by the Napa Legal Institute. The index scores all fifty states on how their laws treat churches, schools, charities and other faith-based groups that hold federal tax-exempt status.
Michigan finished last with an overall score of 34 percent. Washington State came next at 38 percent, followed by Massachusetts at 41 percent. At the top, Alabama scored 80 percent, Kansas 76 percent and Indiana 75 percent.
The institute, a legal group that serves religious organizations, built the index from state laws on matters such as religious exemptions, charitable regulation, tax treatment and constitutional limits on aid to faith-based groups. Michigan has finished at the bottom for two years running. Its state constitution carries a so-called Blaine amendment, a provision from the nineteenth century that restricts public money going to religious institutions, and the institute has pointed to such provisions as a drag on faith-based nonprofits.
The scoring reflects the institute's own choices about which laws to measure and how heavily to weigh them, and a ranking is not a verdict from any court. Still, the picture is plain enough. A church or Christian school in Alabama faces a friendlier legal field than one in Michigan or Washington, though both are American states under the same Constitution and the same First Amendment.
Whose house is it, anyway?
Numbers like these can seem dry. They are not. Behind a score of 34 percent are a pastor wondering whether his food pantry will be treated like a business, a Christian school board asking whether it may hire teachers who actually believe what the school teaches, and a congregation that wants to serve its neighbors without first asking permission to be what it is.
Some policymakers in this country have decided that the church is one more private club to be managed, taxed and tidied up. I would say it as kindly as I can: that gets the order of things backward. The church did not receive its calling from a statehouse, and no statehouse can take it away. The Lord built His church, and He said the gates of hell would not prevail against it.
The first Christians understood this better than we sometimes do today. The rulers of Jerusalem told Peter and John to stop preaching in the name of Jesus. They had the authority to arrest, to beat, to jail. Peter did not shout and he did not plot. He gave a short, steady answer that has echoed down twenty centuries.
"Then Peter and the other apostles answered and said, We ought to obey God rather than men." (Acts 5:29)
Notice what Peter did not say. He did not deny that rulers have a place. Our Lord Himself said, "Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's; and unto God the things that are God's" (Matthew 22:21). A Christian pays his taxes, honors the office, and prays for those who hold it, whatever party they belong to. But the line runs both ways. When the things of Caesar start swallowing the things of God, the believer is bound to say so, graciously and without bitterness, and then to go on doing what God has told him to do.
What the believer does next
If you live in a state near the bottom of that list, my friend, do not despair, and do not become angry. Laws can be changed by honest citizens who vote, write and testify. Many of the top-ranked states earned their place because ordinary church members showed up and asked for fair treatment. That work is worth doing.
But hear this too. No ranking can touch the thing that matters most. The early church grew in cities where it had no protection at all, where being a Christian could cost a man his property or his neck. The gospel did not wait for a favorable score. A pastor who preaches Christ crucified and risen, in a state ranked first or fiftieth, is doing the one work that does not depend on the legislature.
The Lord Jesus gave His people a commission, not a permission slip. Feed the hungry, teach the children, tell the lost that there is forgiveness for sin through the blood of the cross. Whether the statute book is kind or unkind, that charge stands. Keep the church open, keep the doors unlocked, and keep the Word of God in plain view.
Source: Political.org